The coronavirus pandemic had a negative impact on BrewDog’s pubs business, just as it did on the wider hospitality industry. However, this risk factor has – for now – abated.
A key concern for investors has been the reports of a “culture of fear” at BrewDog. Separate BBC articles from 2021 highlighted accusations from former employees that BrewDog was a “sexist boys’ club” and that the company fostered a “toxic” and “misogynistic” work culture. For its part, the company has “accepted mistakes were made” and noted that it “could improve”. In 2022 “several ex-BrewDog workers” accused then-CEO James Watt of “inappropriate behaviour”, according to a BBC Disclosure investigation. Lawyers have described these allegations as false, the BBC notes.
The company has also faced criticism of its green credentials. A group of former staff calling themselves ‘Punks with Purpose’ has accused BrewDog of hypocrisy over its environmental branding and its use of chartered transatlantic flights.
A Financial Times article in 2021 commented that BrewDog “made Blythe Jack, a managing director at private equity firm TSG Consumer Partners, which bought a stake [in BrewDog] in 2017, chair of its board in the wake of the claims” about the company’s culture. However, BrewDog investors are reportedly concerned about the terms of TSG’s involvement with BrewDog. According to the FT article, TSG “is guaranteed an 18% compounding annual return on its 22% holding in the event of an IPO”, with priority given to this agreement over other shareholders. This means that newer investors could lose money even if BrewDog’s value increases. Myrto Lalacos, investment executive at Praetura Ventures, was quoted in the FT as saying that crowdfunding investors would only recoup their investment if the company sold for £2bn or more in 2024.